'Gilligan's Island' Cast Could've Been Absolutely Different

Audiences around the world fell in love with the shipwrecked cast on Gilligan's Island. It's difficult to imagine any other actors in the place of the stars we now know from that sandy beach. Yet, there were a few well-known celebs also in the running to be on the show. Let's take a look at the cast that could have been!

Image Credit: Getty Images / Dawn Wells and "Ginger" characters during Warner Home Video's "Gilligan's Island" DVD Launch Event at FantaSea Yatch Club in Marina del Rey, California, United States.

Image Credit: Getty Images / Dawn Wells and "Ginger" characters during Warner Home Video's "Gilligan's Island" DVD Launch Event at FantaSea Yatch Club in Marina del Rey, California, United States.


The Name Of The Show Could've Been Very Different 

Its been more than five decades since we enjoyed the comical and intriguing islanders on this beloved show. The name we now know like second nature actually has a pretty funny back story. Not only did the show creator find it in a telephone book but the title, "Hogfighter Island" was also being considered!

Image Credit: Getty Images / LOS ANGELES - APRIL 15: GILLIGAN'S ISLAND. Cast posed on ladders in the lagoon. (from left) Jim Backus (as Thurston Howell III); in foreground: Bob Denver (as Gilligan); Dawn Wells (as Mary Ann Summers); Alan Hale, Jr. (as The Skipper, Jonas Grumby); Russell Johnson (as The Professor, Roy Hinkley); Natalie Schafer (as Mrs. Lovey Howell) and Tina Louise (as Ginger Grant). Image dated April 15, 1966.

Image Credit: Getty Images / LOS ANGELES - APRIL 15: GILLIGAN'S ISLAND. Cast posed on ladders in the lagoon. (from left) Jim Backus (as Thurston Howell III); in foreground: Bob Denver (as Gilligan); Dawn Wells (as Mary Ann Summers); Alan Hale, Jr. (as The Skipper, Jonas Grumby); Russell Johnson (as The Professor, Roy Hinkley); Natalie Schafer (as Mrs. Lovey Howell) and Tina Louise (as Ginger Grant). Image dated April 15, 1966.


They Fooled Us With The Location... Or Did They? 

One of the other surprising facts linked to the series is the location. While viewers are led to believe it plays off on some faraway island, this is far from the truth. The entire series was shot on set in California. In fact, the lagoon display we saw on our screens was completely man-made. 

Image Credit: Getty Images / Circa 1966, American actors, left to right, Bob Denver, Alan Hale Jr. (1918-1990) and Russell Johnson attempt to use a homemade CB radio to contact civilization in a still from the television comedy show 'Gilligan's Island'.

Image Credit: Getty Images / Circa 1966, American actors, left to right, Bob Denver, Alan Hale Jr. (1918-1990) and Russell Johnson attempt to use a homemade CB radio to contact civilization in a still from the television comedy show 'Gilligan's Island'.

For many viewers, there was never a doubt insight that they were being fooled by an off-location production. Yet, some super sleuths did discover a few giveaways like the city skyline and some other curious landmarks. It seems not everyone was blinded by the location's flaws.  

Image Credit: Getty Images / Pop Culture Award Winners The Cast of Gilligan's Island pose backstage at the 2nd Annual TV Land Awards held on March 7, 2004 at The Hollywood Palladium, in Hollywood, California.

Image Credit: Getty Images / Pop Culture Award Winners The Cast of Gilligan's Island pose backstage at the 2nd Annual TV Land Awards held on March 7, 2004 at The Hollywood Palladium, in Hollywood, California.


The Actress Who Should Not Have Been Cast 

If there was one case where a different star should truly have landed the role, it is with Natalie Schafer. The actress portrayed the millionaire socialite Lovey Howell. Her performance was great and she was certainly a highlight ever episode but she was not a fan of the show.

Image Credit: Getty Images / From left to right, [sultry] Ginger (Tina Louise), girl-next-door Mary Ann (Dawn Wells), and millionairess Mrs. Howell (Natalie Schaefer) in a scene from the 1960s television comedy Gilligan's Island. 1964-1967.

Image Credit: Getty Images / From left to right, [sultry] Ginger (Tina Louise), girl-next-door Mary Ann (Dawn Wells), and millionairess Mrs. Howell (Natalie Schaefer) in a scene from the 1960s television comedy Gilligan's Island. 1964-1967.

While we all fell madly in love with her hilarious facial expressions and emotive acting, she was not always having the greatest time. There were various aspects of the show that were not to her liking. Either way, Natalie did a good job of concealing her real feelings on the screen. 

Image Credit: Getty Images / Actors E.J. Peaker, left, and Steve Vinovich rehearse their lines on the set of the upcoming television movie, "Surviving Gilligan''s Island: The Incredibly True Story Of The Longest Three-Hour Tour In History" June 2001 in Malibu, CA.

Image Credit: Getty Images / Actors E.J. Peaker, left, and Steve Vinovich rehearse their lines on the set of the upcoming television movie, "Surviving Gilligan''s Island: The Incredibly True Story Of The Longest Three-Hour Tour In History" June 2001 in Malibu, CA.


Casting The Skipper: Carroll O'Connor 

There were many actors standing in the line for an audition to be the fantastic Skipper. When the masses had been scaled down, one specific star was in the running. It was none other than Carroll O'Connor. While he didn't land it, he still went on to gain fame for his fantastic portrayal in "All in the Family.

Image Credit: Getty Images / Jean Stapleton and Carroll O'Connor during Actors Arrive for "All In The Family" Taping - February 8, 1972 at CBS Television City in Los Angeles, California, United States.

Image Credit: Getty Images / Jean Stapleton and Carroll O'Connor during Actors Arrive for "All In The Family" Taping - February 8, 1972 at CBS Television City in Los Angeles, California, United States.


Alan Hale Jr as The Real Skipper 

Alan Hale Jr. is of course the man who nabbed the coveted spot at the Skipper on Gilligan's Island. One of the key features of his audition was linked to his arrival. The actor pitched up via horseback, making quite the entrance and leaving a lasting impression. 

Image Credit: Getty Images / American actor Alan Hale Jr. (1918 - 1990), as the Skipper, in a scene from an episode of the television comedy 'Gilligan's Island' entitled 'Nyet Nyet, Not Yet,' Los Angeles, California, September 30, 1965.

Image Credit: Getty Images / American actor Alan Hale Jr. (1918 - 1990), as the Skipper, in a scene from an episode of the television comedy 'Gilligan's Island' entitled 'Nyet Nyet, Not Yet,' Los Angeles, California, September 30, 1965.


Casting Gilligan: Jerry Van Dyke 

One of the younger but also famous Van Dyke brothers, Jerry, was also a potential casting option on the hit series. In fact, the creator of the show really favored him as the right man for the lead character. Yet, Jerry gave up the role of a lifetime to star in the short-lived and disappointing "My Mother the Car." 

Image Credit: Getty Images / Jerry Van Dyke and Dick Van Dyke during 7th Annual American Comedy Awards at Shrine Exposition Center in Los Angeles, California, United States.

Image Credit: Getty Images / Jerry Van Dyke and Dick Van Dyke during 7th Annual American Comedy Awards at Shrine Exposition Center in Los Angeles, California, United States.


Bob Denver as The One and Only Gilligan 

The leading role went to the right man at the end of the day and fans of the series can't imagine anyone but Bob Denver, as the show's narrative anchor. What a phenomenal job he did, Bob truly commanded the screen and kept audiences intrigued episode after episode. 

Image Credit: Getty Images / CBS television situation comedy program Gilligan's Island, episode 'Home Sweet Hut.' Filmed at the lagoon, CBS Studio Center, Studio City, CA. Image date, March 3, 1964. Original broadcast date October 3, 1964. Pictured is Bob Denver (as Gilligan).

Image Credit: Getty Images / CBS television situation comedy program Gilligan's Island, episode 'Home Sweet Hut.' Filmed at the lagoon, CBS Studio Center, Studio City, CA. Image date, March 3, 1964. Original broadcast date October 3, 1964. Pictured is Bob Denver (as Gilligan).


Casting "Ginger": Jayne Mansfield 

Jayne Mansfield is a name known far and wide but few realize she was in the running to star on Gilligan's Island! The popular blonde bombshell chose to pass over the role because she did not want to be typecast as only a sultry movie star character that is placed in a box. 

Image Credit: Getty Images / JANUARY 4, 1957: Actress Jayne Mansfield poses during a Liberace party in Los Angeles,California.

Image Credit: Getty Images / JANUARY 4, 1957: Actress Jayne Mansfield poses during a Liberace party in Los Angeles,California.


Tina Louise Perfected "Ginger" Afterall 

Tina Louise was consequently the lady who took on the role of Ginger, and what a great job she did! While she refused to star in the TV movies and animated series spin-offs that came after the series ended, she still had a real love for the show and her fellow castmates.

Image Credit: Getty Images / American actress Tina Louise, as Ginger, wraps her arms around the 'shoulders' of a robot (played by Bob D'Arcy) in a scene from an episode of the television comedy 'Gilligan's Island' entitled 'Gilligan's Living Doll,' Los Angeles, California, November 18, 1965.

Image Credit: Getty Images / American actress Tina Louise, as Ginger, wraps her arms around the 'shoulders' of a robot (played by Bob D'Arcy) in a scene from an episode of the television comedy 'Gilligan's Island' entitled 'Gilligan's Living Doll,' Los Angeles, California, November 18, 1965.


Casting Another "Ginger": Kit Smythe 

Yes, you read correctly, there was indeed another Ginger! Kit Smythe, the red-haired actress we are all familiar with, also stood a chance at playing this character. Kit Smythe actually starred in the pilot episode, taking on the part of a bombshell secretary. Her role was later replaced by Tina Louise, the bombshell movie star, Ginger. 

Image Credit: Getty Images / NOVEMBER 18: Gilligan's Island cast members, from left, Dawn Wells (as Mary Ann Summers), Jim Backus (as Thurston Howell III), Natalie Schafer (as Mrs. Lovey Howell), Russell Johnson (as Professor Roy Hinkley), Alan Hale, Jr. (as The Skipper Jonas Grumby, seated), Bob Denver (as Gilligan) and Tina Louise (as Ginger Grant) appearing in episode: "Gilligan's Living Doll."

Image Credit: Getty Images / NOVEMBER 18: Gilligan's Island cast members, from left, Dawn Wells (as Mary Ann Summers), Jim Backus (as Thurston Howell III), Natalie Schafer (as Mrs. Lovey Howell), Russell Johnson (as Professor Roy Hinkley), Alan Hale, Jr. (as The Skipper Jonas Grumby, seated), Bob Denver (as Gilligan) and Tina Louise (as Ginger Grant) appearing in episode: "Gilligan's Living Doll."


Casting Two Contenders For "Mary Ann": Nancy McCarthy and Raquel Welch 

Nancy McCarthy gained some luck when she was cast in the original pilot as a rough around the edges version of Mary Ann. Her name was Bunny and she starred as a secretary but her character was later replaced with the Mary Ann character we now know and love. 

Image Credit: Getty Images / Cast Members (l-r) Actor Bob Denver, Creator of "Gilligan's Island" Sherwood Schwarz Actress Dawn Wells and Actor Russell Johnson arrive at the launch party for "Gilligan's Island: The Complete First Season" on February 03, 2004 in Marina del Rey, California.

Image Credit: Getty Images / Cast Members (l-r) Actor Bob Denver, Creator of "Gilligan's Island" Sherwood Schwarz Actress Dawn Wells and Actor Russell Johnson arrive at the launch party for "Gilligan's Island: The Complete First Season" on February 03, 2004 in Marina del Rey, California.

When the pilot episode underwent a makeover, the creators of Gilligan's Island were trying to find the perfect girl-next-door. Raquel Welch did a screen test for this role but ultimately it did not suit her sultry style. She was simply lacking the sweetness and soft natured touch the character needed.  

Image Credit: Getty Images / The stunning American actress Raquel Welch poses for a photoshoot in 1967.

Image Credit: Getty Images / The stunning American actress Raquel Welch poses for a photoshoot in 1967.


Dawn Wells Remains The Sweet Old Favorite "Mary Ann"

Dawn Wells will forever be remembered for her stint on the series. Even though it was more than 50 years ago, the actress still thinks back on her days as the iconic Mary Ann fondly. She feels "blessed" to have been part of such a great and legendary show. She said

“Many of my favorite scenes were the dream sequences when I got to play other characters. There was one episode when I get hit on the head and imagine I’m Ginger. Tina was such a great sport about me mimicking her voice.”

Image Credit: Getty Images / Gilligan's Island cast members, from left, Dawn Wells (as Mary Ann Summers, as flower seller) and Russell Johnson (as Professor Roy Hinkley, as prosecutor) in the episode: "And Then There Were None." Image dated October 19, 1966.

Image Credit: Getty Images / Gilligan's Island cast members, from left, Dawn Wells (as Mary Ann Summers, as flower seller) and Russell Johnson (as Professor Roy Hinkley, as prosecutor) in the episode: "And Then There Were None." Image dated October 19, 1966.


Casting Dabney Coleman and John Gabriel as the Professor

He was the actor from "Tootsie," Dabney Coleman tried his hand at a part on Gilligan's Island but after an unsuccessful screen test, it was not meant to be. John Gabriel then nabbed the role, but only for a short while. When he didn't make magic on screen for the pilot, he too was recast.  

Image Credit: Getty Images / THE TONIGHT SHOW STARRING JOHNNY CARSON -- Pictured: (l-r) Actor Dabney Coleman during an interview with host Johnny Carson on April 25, 1991.

Image Credit: Getty Images / THE TONIGHT SHOW STARRING JOHNNY CARSON -- Pictured: (l-r) Actor Dabney Coleman during an interview with host Johnny Carson on April 25, 1991.

This was not the end of these actors, and both of them went on to gain fame and awards in other avenues and ventures. For example, Dabney Coleman now has some impressive credits to his name. These include, "That Girl," "Kojak" and "The Mary Tyler Moore Show."

Image Credit: Getty Images / Actor Dabney Coleman arrives at AFI FEST 2016 Presented by Audi - Opening Night - Premiere of 20th Century Fox's 'Rules Don't Apply' at TCL Chinese Theatre on November 10, 2016 in Hollywood, California.

Image Credit: Getty Images / Actor Dabney Coleman arrives at AFI FEST 2016 Presented by Audi - Opening Night - Premiere of 20th Century Fox's 'Rules Don't Apply' at TCL Chinese Theatre on November 10, 2016 in Hollywood, California.


There Can Only Be One Professor: Russell Johnson 

There was eventually only one man who could handle the role of the professor. That man was of course Russell Johnson and what a fantastic Professor he was. In total, he was in 98 of the 99 episodes and went on to have an impressive career after the series.

Image Credit: Getty Images / Actors Bob Denver, left, who starred as "Gilligan" and Russell Johnson who starred as "The Professor" on the television comedy "Gilligan's Island" pose for a photograph during a reunion November 12, 2000 in Miami.

Image Credit: Getty Images / Actors Bob Denver, left, who starred as "Gilligan" and Russell Johnson who starred as "The Professor" on the television comedy "Gilligan's Island" pose for a photograph during a reunion November 12, 2000 in Miami.

On his personal website he shared the following about his love for Gilligan's Island: 

"I think, what I love most at this point in time in the long life of Gilligan's Island is the positive, intelligent nature of longtime Gilligan aficionados. It amazes me. I have received mail throughout the years from young viewers from all over the world, year after year.

Image Credit: Getty Images / 2004 TV Land Awards Airing March 17, 2004 - Show Russell Johnson and Dawn Wells.

Image Credit: Getty Images / 2004 TV Land Awards Airing March 17, 2004 - Show Russell Johnson and Dawn Wells.


The Impact Of The Professor's Character

Russell did such a stellar job of portraying his role that many fans around the world were inspired to follow in his footsteps. The actor was often overcome with joy when he heard stories of how his character made a difference. He explained these instances as follows: 

"[They] were so influenced by the Professor's smarts that they became science buffs and are now real professors, doctors and scientists. It makes me proud."

Image Credit: Getty Images / Gilligan's Island cast members, from left, Dawn Wells (as Mary Ann Summers, as flower seller) and Russell Johnson (as Professor Roy Hinkley, as prosecutor) in the episode: "And Then There Were None." Image dated October 19, 1966.

Image Credit: Getty Images / Gilligan's Island cast members, from left, Dawn Wells (as Mary Ann Summers, as flower seller) and Russell Johnson (as Professor Roy Hinkley, as prosecutor) in the episode: "And Then There Were None." Image dated October 19, 1966.


A Possibility At Off-Screen Love: Dawn Wells & Russell Johnson 

Mr. and Mrs. Howell's characters may have been the only loved up couple on the series but the off-screen romance was brewing without the knowledge of the viewers. Dawn Wells aka Mary Ann hinted at this during an interview for “Oprah: Where Are They Now?”

Image Credit: Getty Images / Actress Dawn Wells and Russell Johnson attend the book party for Dawn Wells "Mary Ann's Gilligan's Island Cookbook" on December 4, 1993 at the Book Soup Book Store in Los Angeles, California.

Image Credit: Getty Images / Actress Dawn Wells and Russell Johnson attend the book party for Dawn Wells "Mary Ann's Gilligan's Island Cookbook" on December 4, 1993 at the Book Soup Book Store in Los Angeles, California.

She was quite candid about her belief that she and Russell Johnson aka the Professor, could have struck up a relationship of timing was on their side. She said:

“If either one of us had been single or both of us had been single, there would have been some chemistry. He had the best sense of humor. He was the funniest. And he was a hunk!”

Image Credit: Getty Images / Actors (L-R) Dawn Wells, Russell Johnson, Tina Louise & Bob Denver fr. TV's Gilligan's Island at trading card show.

Image Credit: Getty Images / Actors (L-R) Dawn Wells, Russell Johnson, Tina Louise & Bob Denver fr. TV's Gilligan's Island at trading card show.


Remembering The Professor From Mary Ann's Perspective 

Russell Johnson is one of the show's legends who has since passed away. However, this does not mean the fans will forget the great acting and impact he and various others had on the TV world and life in general. Dawn Well aka Mary Ann was quick to admit that she does still “miss him.”

Image Credit: Getty Images / Filmed at the lagoon, CBS Studio Center, Studio City, CA. Image date, March 3, 1964. Original broadcast date October 3, 1964. Pictured from left is Russell Johnson (as Professor Roy Hinkley), Dawn Wells (as Mary Ann Summers), Alan Hale Jr. (as Jonas 'The Skipper' Grumby), Natalie Schafer (as Mrs. Lovey Howell), Jim Backus (as Thurston Howell III), Tina Louise (as Ginger).

Image Credit: Getty Images / Filmed at the lagoon, CBS Studio Center, Studio City, CA. Image date, March 3, 1964. Original broadcast date October 3, 1964. Pictured from left is Russell Johnson (as Professor Roy Hinkley), Dawn Wells (as Mary Ann Summers), Alan Hale Jr. (as Jonas 'The Skipper' Grumby), Natalie Schafer (as Mrs. Lovey Howell), Jim Backus (as Thurston Howell III), Tina Louise (as Ginger).

This series was one of a kind. Not only did it catapult many stars to fame but it became a household name. Do you think the actors and actresses who narrowly missed out on these roles regret it? Leave us your comments and be sure to click the charge button! 

Sources: Fox News, Daily News, Huff Post, Palm Beach Post

Related posts
Wikimedia Commons
TV Shows Nov 28, 2019
Private Life Secrets of 'I Love Lucy' Star William Frawley Revealed: Twisted Destiny Before, During and After the Show
Getty Images
TV Shows Nov 04, 2019
Calling All 'Jeopardy' Fans: Meet Alex Trebek's Wonderful Family
TV Shows Sep 02, 2019
Family Tragedy of Laura Ingalls: Author of the Book That Created a Massively Popular TV Show
Wikimedia Commons
TV Shows Aug 27, 2019
Unexpected Facts About 'The Brady Bunch' That Change Everything

Please disable your AdBlocker

Advertising helps us continue to provide quality content. For instant unlimited access. Please disable your AdBlocker on our site and refresh the page.